In The Loop Travel
  • Home
  • Destinations
    • The Americas
    • Caribbean
    • Mexico
    • Europe
    • Asia/Pacific
    • Africa
  • Fitness
  • Cruising
  • Travel Tips
  • Videos
  • Work With Us
  • My Work
  • About
  • Colorado Craft Brewery Guide
  • Media Kit
  • TBIN Influencer Network

I Probed My Sailing Personalities in Two Weeks on the Waterways

7/14/2016

15 Comments

 
When Cruise Styles Clash: Un-Cruise Adventures
Picture
VS.
Royal Caribbean's Harmony of the Seas
Picture
By John Roberts

Think of two cruise voyages that couldn't be more different from each other.

You might have an idea of certain types of sailings that could fit that request, but I think I nailed it with a pair of trips I took on consecutive weeks.

I ventured into the wilds of Alaska on a small-ship expedition with Un-Cruise Adventures and followed up by sailing the inaugural voyage on Harmony of the Seas, the largest cruise ship in the world, a mammoth floating complex that can carry almost 6,800 people.

This wasn't on purpose. My schedule just worked out that way, and the stark contrasts helped me learn a lot about why people might like each style of cruise -- and aside from suffering a bit of cruise-induced schizophrenia, I also learned that I can have a good time on either type of trip. Find out what style of cruise best fits your personality by checking my comparison of an Un-Cruise Adventures cruise in Alaska vs. Royal Caribbean's Harmony of the Seas.
                                                        - - -
On Un-Cruise Adventures' Wilderness Explorer, I cruised with 35 other passengers. Luckily, we got along very well. If we didn't, there isn't any place to hide. On Harmony of the Seas, a ship that stretches more than 1,000 feet long and rises some 16 decks, you have options. Bump into a group of fellow travelers who are a bit disagreeable -- maybe they are discussing the U.S. election season too vehemently, for example -- you can politely excuse yourself (just say you are heading to the bar for another beer), and you never have to see them again . . . for an entire week. There is plenty of space for everyone!

I loved going into the brilliant wilderness of Alaska every day to hike, swim, kayak and spot creatures in their natural habitat. Again, I was lucky. I had fantastic sunny weather during my cruise. Alaska is notorious for periods of heavy rain, and while this doesn't prohibit going out for hikes and such, those who are bad-weather averse might not want to venture out. The destination is the attraction for Un-Cruise voyages, so if you don't get off the ship for a daily activity, your entertainment options become quite limited. Although, there is always the bar and the refreshing embrace of Alaska Brewing Co.'s tasty beers.

The ship is the destination for many people who choose a vacation on Harmony of the Seas, and you get to see cruisers in their natural habitat, foraging at the buffet and turning just the right color of crimson while baking the pale flesh in the sun. The ship also features tons of fun stuff to do. Families and friends can travel together with no worries about having to agree on what to do each day. There is something for everyone.

Harmony of the Seas has a 10-story dry slide, three waterslides, rock climbing walls, zip line, ice skating rink and FlowRider surfing simulators, to name some of the dozens of activities aside from the large pool areas, fitness center, theaters with large-scale variety and Broadway-style shows. You can watch a production of "Grease."

Whale watching is a highlight on Un-Cruise sailings, and we spotted orcas "thisclose" to our ship. Whale watching on Harmony of the Seas . . . (insert your own joke; I'm not going there!).

Your workouts on the Un-Cruise Adventures ship consist of epic hikes and paddling sessions while out in the wilderness. Trust me, this is an awesome way to challenge yourself. A small space on an upper deck of the four-deck boat also has room for a workout, with a couple dumbbells, yoga mats, a stationary bike and an elliptical machine.

Harmony of the Seas features a full-scale gym with all the equipment you would find at the best health clubs on land and offers a range of fitness classes, too. Plus, the attached spa is the place to go for massages and other treatments like facials, wraps, nails and hair styling.
On an Un-Cruise ship, you'll have to do your own styling and treatments (what happens in your cabin is your business).

On Harmony of the Seas and any big cruise ship, you can get food at almost all hours of the day -- from about two dozen restaurants, including a massive buffet. Room service is also a quick phone call away.

It's true, the constant eating and drinking is a big part of the attraction for many cruisers on these big ships.

You also get well fed with delicious regional cuisine on an Un-Cruise Adventures voyage in Alaska, too. With king crab, salmon, steaks and other delicacies on the menu. It's just that meal times are set -- with breakfast and lunch buffets serving a variety of dishes (and you can always get seconds) -- and the dining venue is the same for everyone for each meal. So, there is not an endless temptation to consume. One bar, one dining room on Un-Cruise. And no room service.

On Harmony of the Seas: Dozens of bars and lounges and a similar number of eateries. "Ooh, ice cream! Yes, I'll have a cone!"

It never ends. You'll wander past grills filled with hot dogs, burgers and fries. Or a coffee shop that just happens to have tasty pastries, cookies or sandwiches at the ready.

Un-Cruise ships offer the chance for daily excursions ranging from hikes, walks, standup paddleboarding, skiff tours, kayaking tours up fjords and small boat trips to get close to a calving glacier or powerful waterfall. Even snorkeling! The sports marina opens off the back of the ship giving access to nature. You even can take a plunge into the chilly waters at the end of the trip. (It's a fun bonding ritual for cruisers who have shared a week's worth of adventures).

Harmony of the Seas offers a range of excursions that differ based on what destination you visit. So, you can get a variety of active challenges such as snorkeling and bike tours and such. You also might just take a city tour or go for a relaxing day at a stunning Caribbean beach. Buying a tour through the cruise ship means you might end up in a larger group traveling by bus depending on how popular the excursion is. You also pay extra for these activities. On Un-Cruise, the daily activities are always about getting out into the wilderness of Alaska and are included in your fare.

Both ships have hot tubs! It's awesome to sail near a glacier or through a gorge looking up at the mountains from the comfort of a hot tub while enjoying a craft beer in Alaska.

It's also wonderful to watch a Caribbean sunset and play in the nearby pools during a sea day on Harmony of the Seas.

As you can imagine, packing for each ship is quite different. No need for rain gear on Harmony of the Seas. You'd better pack your rain boots, pants and jacket for Un-Cruise Adventures trips in Alaska (you can rent gear, too) or you will have to miss a day of activities, which send you out onto the trails, rain or shine.

For Harmony of the Seas, you might decide to pack dresses or suits and ties for formal nights, dinners and dancing, etc. The cabins are tiny on Un-Cruise Adventures Alaska ships, with decor that is far more functional than fancy. Your bathroom also could be a typical "marine head" with the toilet/shower combo packed into a tiny space.

Harmony of the Seas offers staterooms with large balconies and suites that are as big as some small apartments. The daily program for a cruise on Harmony of the Seas offers a wide array of activities designed to keep a diverse passenger base having fun. Trivia, bellyflop contests, art auctions, late-night comedy shows, themed dance parties and 3-on-3 basketball or blackjack tournaments, for example.

The end-of-day program for Un-Cruise sailings consist simply of an enrichment talk on the geography, animals or history of the regions you visit.

I'm sure there are many more points to compare that show just how different each style of cruising is and thus just how startling it was for me to go directly from the serenity and closeness of a small group of almost 100 percent like-minded travelers looking to venture out into the Last Frontier on what was a bucket-list type of trip for many to the organized chaos and buzzing energy that pervades the world's largest cruise ship.

I have long been a chameleon as a traveler. I am easy. I love all types of adventures and easily adapt to all sorts of environments and conditions. These back-to-back weeks put the incredible differences between these two types of sailings into stark relief, however, and I would prefer a break to process one wonderful experience before jumping into the next. But sometimes my schedule is too packed for me to have a choice.

My aim here was to give details about each type of cruising so that you will know what you are getting into. What type of cruise suits your personality? Harmony of the Seas vs. Un-Cruise Adventures?

Some of you will know right away.

Want to party with friends and family and hang with fellow revelers (among which you probably will find a few new friends) who are out to have a good time? Pick Harmony of the Seas.

Want to party with nature? And ponder your small place in this in this world while exploring the wonders of the amazing wilds and making new friends in a more chill and intimate setting? Take an Un-Cruise Adventures voyage in Alaska.

Or you just might want to try each type of cruise for yourself to see what I'm talking about.
Just don't try them out in consecutive weeks like I did.
 
Thanks for reading and happy cruising, whatever your style.
JR
Subscribe today to get the latest reviews, tips and tricks to help you have your best adventure ever.

15 Comments
Walt
7/15/2016 02:52:25 pm

Nice report, John. Thank you. Can you provide some insight into the cost of each cruise, at least relative to one another?

Reply
JR
7/15/2016 05:27:07 pm

Hey Walt. Thanks for reading and your kind comments. Good detail to add and I did so above. Harmony is about $1,100 pp for a weeklong cruise and Un-Cruise would start at about $2,300. Cheers! -- JR

Reply
Linda Androlia link
7/22/2016 12:58:31 am

Great article, but... your comment on price is so missing information. On an Un-Cruise as most all expedition ships you can leave your wallet at home. There are no extras, Unless you call their gift shop of maybe two sweatshirts and hats a place to spend your money. The mega ships in my opinion use their price as their loss leader. It is once on the ship that you are marketed to spend on so many extras. Liquor, special ice cream, special coffees, special dinning rooms, gift shops galore.... etc etc..

JR
7/22/2016 02:29:33 am

Of course, Linda. You are right. This article was not meant to compare the cruises on price at all. Just to discuss the overall styles and experiences you will have.
Thanks for reading, and happy sailing!

Dave
7/24/2016 12:22:02 pm

That's not a real comparison of cost because virtually all excursions are included with the Un-Cruise fare while none of them are included in the large ship cost.

KF
7/20/2016 08:51:46 pm

It is a bit like comparing apples to oranges...if you did supplemental excursions on the large cruise lines (kayaking, etc) the costs would be more comparable.

Reply
JR
7/21/2016 01:08:49 pm

True. I'd say these two types of cruises are exactly like apples and oranges. I suggest trying both if possible. They each can be a really amazing time, but obviously for different reasons. Thanks for reading and commenting.
Best,
JR

Reply
Dave
7/24/2016 12:24:21 pm

We've done both and for the two ships compared, we'll take Un-Cruise every time. We like large ship cruises just not on ships that large.

Lisa
7/21/2016 01:23:00 am

Hi John. I enjoyed your article. We traveled on the Safari Explorer recently and had a terrific time, despite having a lot of rain. If a nature experience is what a potential Cruiser is looking for, and you're comfortable with small group bonding, I would absolutely recommend an Un-Cruise.

Reply
JR
7/21/2016 01:11:22 pm

Hi Lisa,
I was so lucky to have little rain. I'm sure the experience is amazing wither way, but the ideal conditions made each day in Alaska with UN-CRUISE incredible. You are right.
Thanks for popping by. Come back often. :)
JR

Reply
Lisa
7/21/2016 03:15:41 pm

Hi JR. The guides were pretty philosophical about the weather. They said there's no bad weather only bad gear. Fortunately they had enough rubber boots and waterproof pants to pass out to everyone who needed them. It was a good way to look at things and it helped us keep the weather in perspective as well as keeping our sense of humors when we were cold and wet. The hot toddies helped too!

Taryn Waros link
7/21/2016 12:55:00 pm

My experience is with Un-Cruise Adventures and the intimacy of a group of 35 people. My mom went to Alaska on one of the huge cruise ships, about 3500 people. Her biggest memory was the time spent in lines. No thanks!

Reply
JR
7/21/2016 01:13:25 pm

Isn't it just fabulous on the Un-Cruise voyage? Those lines, especially at the buffets, are a serious drawback for massive ship, indeed.
Thanks so much for reading
JR

Reply
Willey Wilson link
7/23/2016 04:46:22 pm

$2300 for a cruise? Serious?

Reply
JR
7/25/2016 10:15:18 am

Hi Willey,
Different cruises have different levels of luxury and inclusive pricing. You can find cruise pricing all over the board. I was just on a ship that starts waaaay higher than $2,300. I think the industry is seeking to offer experiences that suit all tastes and incomes.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Categories

    All
    Africa
    AIDA Cruises
    Alaska
    Albatros Expeditions
    Alicante
    AmaWaterways
    Amber Cove
    American Queen Steamboat Company
    American Queen Voyages
    Amsterdam
    Antarctica
    Antigua
    Arctic
    Arizona
    Aruba
    Asia
    Atlas Ocean Voyages
    Australia
    Austria
    Avalon Waterways
    Backroads
    Bahamas
    Barbados
    Barcelona
    Belize
    Blue World Voyages
    Bonaire
    Bora Bora
    Brooklyn
    Budapest
    Burma
    Cabo San Lucas
    Cadiz
    California
    Cambodia
    Cancun
    Caribbean
    Carnival Cruise
    Celebrity Cruises
    Celestyal Cruises
    Christmas Markets
    Cologne
    Colombia
    Colorado
    Corfu
    Costa Rica
    Cozumel
    Craft Beer
    Croatia
    Crystal Cruises
    Cuba
    Curacao
    Dominican Republic
    Dubrovnik
    Egypt
    Emerald Cruises
    Emerald Waterways
    Europe
    Expat Life
    Explora Journeys
    Fathom Travel
    Fitness
    Florida
    Fort Lauderdale
    France
    French Polynesia
    Galapagos
    Galveston
    Germany
    Grand Cayman
    Greece
    Grenada
    Guatemala
    Halifax
    Harmony Of The Seas
    Hawaii
    High Line Park
    Hiking
    Holland America
    Hong Kong
    Houston
    Hungary
    Ibiza
    Iceland
    Isla Mujeres
    Italy
    Jim Thorpe
    Key West
    Kotor
    Labadee
    Lake Minnewaska
    Las Vegas
    Lisbon
    Lithuania
    London
    London Eye
    Maine
    Malaga
    Mexico
    Miami
    Minnesota
    Mississippi River
    Monte Carlo
    Montenegro
    Monterey
    Montreal
    Moorea
    MSC Cruises
    MSC Divina
    Netherlands
    Newfoundland
    New Jersey
    New Orleans
    New York
    New York City
    New Zealand
    North Carolina
    Norway
    Norwegian Cruise Line
    Nuremberg
    Oceania Cruises
    Oregon
    Orlando
    Panama
    Panama Canal
    Passau
    Paul Gauguin
    Paul Gauguin Cruises
    Pennsylvania
    Philadelphia
    Pickleball
    Ponant
    Portugal
    Prague
    Princess Cruises
    Puerto-rico
    Queens
    Regensburg
    Regent Seven Seas
    Rome
    Royal Caribbean
    Saint-Tropez
    San Francisco
    Santorini
    Scenic Cruises
    Scottsdale
    Seabourn
    SeaDream Yacht Club
    Sicily
    Silversea
    Sintra
    Sorrento
    Spain
    Star Clippers
    St. Maarten
    St. Thomas
    Symphony Of The Seas
    Tahiti
    Travel Gear
    Travel Tips
    Tunisia
    Turkey
    Turks And Caicos
    UnCruise
    Un-Cruise Adventures
    UnCruise Adventures
    Universal's Islands Of Adventure
    Uniworld
    Utah
    Utica
    Utica Boilermaker 15K
    Vienna
    Vietnam
    Viking Cruises
    Washington
    Windstar Cruises
    Wisconsin

    Archives

    January 2023
    December 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014

    RSS Feed

Copyright © 2013 | All rights reserved | Ewing, New Jersey.
Contact | About | Media Kit